Netflix’s attempt to dismiss a defamation lawsuit filed by Fiona Harvey, the inspiration for a character in the series *Baby Reindeer*, has been unsuccessful. Harvey alleges that the show conveyed “brutal lies” about her to a global audience of over 50 million viewers.
The series, created by Richard Gadd, is marketed as “a true story,” but the judge determined that several key events, including a conviction for stalking, did not occur. Netflix has stated its intention to defend the case vigorously, supporting Gadd’s right to share his narrative.
Judge Gary Klausner noted significant differences between stalking and a legal conviction for stalking. He highlighted substantial discrepancies between reality and the depiction in the series. Harvey denied allegations of stalking a police officer, sexually assaulting Gadd, and other violent actions attributed to her character.
While Netflix argued that the portrayals were “substantially true,” the judge emphasized the distinctions between actions like inappropriate touching and sexual assault. He also pointed out that the original stage play had suggested some details might be fictional.
The judge expressed concerns that Netflix showed “reckless disregard” for the truth by presenting the series as a straightforward true story. Although Netflix claimed viewers would recognize the show as fictionalized drama, Klausner disagreed, stating the first episode clearly presents it as factual.
Despite some dismissals in Harvey’s claims, including negligence and punitive damages, the court recognized the specific similarities between her and the character Martha, countering Netflix’s assertion that she could not be easily identified.
*Baby Reindeer* has been a major success, recently winning six Emmy Awards.